Review: JERRY’S GIRLS, Menier Chocolate Factory

Photo credit: Tristram Kenton

For the most part, a musical theatre revue does what it says on the tin. Jerry’s Girls is an enjoyable whistle-stop tour through the back catalogue of the revered composer Jerry Herman, performed by an established trio of West End triple-threats.

Here, the Menier audience is treated to stalwart Jessica Martin, alongside Cassidy Janson and Julie Yamanee. All three women do a sterling job in bringing alive Herman’s hits spanning decades, although the song list does rely heavily on both Mame and Hello, Dolly!, the latter of which is set to receive a London revival this summer.

At its heart, Jerry’s Girls is a bit of a stagey fever dream. There is no pause for breath and the women move seamlessly between hits such as ‘Put on Your Sunday Clothes’ and ‘Movies Were Movies’, connected by the somewhat loose plot of the trio being part of - one would assume - a Jerry Herman musical revue.

The fast-paced, toe-tapping ensemble numbers take place, for the most part, in front of a big red curtain, while Herman’s more thoughtful, touching numbers are reserved for when the three women retreat to their dressing rooms, complete with Hollywood-lit mirrors. The transitions between the two settings feel a little clunky and contrived at times but for this type of revue, it’s best not to overthink it.

Jerry’s Girls is at its best when all three women are performing together, hoofing away to nostalgic Broadway show tunes. Martin brings a certain gravitas to the group, although she’s not afraid to be the butt of the jokes either, while Janson simpers, demonstrating why exactly why she is an established West End leading lady. But it is Yammanee who proves the highlight, her comic touch lending itself naturally alongside her wonderful vocal ability.

It’s a very basic production, both in terms of its concept and choreography. The ‘plot’ is a little distracting and unnecessary; in fact, Alex Parker’s recent concert held at Cadogan Hall set the standard for how Herman’s music ought to be performed outside of their intended shows. Unfortunately, Jerry’s Girls lacks in genuine sparkle and charisma.

However, it is also a show that says - to quote that famous La Cage Aux Folles number - ‘I Am What I Am’. Or, rather, it is what it is. At two hours including an interval, this is a quick spin through Herman’s hits, performed beautifully by a talented trio of women. Is it really needed? Probably not. Is it a couple of hours of light fun for a musical theatre obsessive? Definitely.

*** Three stars

Reviewed by: Tom Ambrose

Jerry’s Girls plays at the Menier Chocolate Factory until 29th June, with further information here.